‘Space exploration is like going to Olympics’: Shrinivas Kulkarni


Missions like manned space stations, lunar bases, or interplanetary exploration are aspirational and require thorough analysis, according to Shrinivas R Kulkarni, George Ellery Hale professor of astronomy and planetary science at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech), US. In a conversation with ET on the sidelines of the Infosys Science Foundation award ceremony, Kulkarni drew parallels between India’s space endeavours and participating in the Olympics, calling it an “expensive game”.

“When I say cultural choices, it’s like asking, ‘Should India participate in the Olympics?’ If India doesn’t participate, nothing happens. If it does, there’s no direct impact either,” the US-based astronomer and brother of philanthropist Sudha Murty said.

Taking note

Known for the discovery of the first millisecond pulsar, the first brown dwarf, Kulkarni acknowledged that India’s Astrostat mission (launched in 2023) is significant, but noted that India cannot yet be compared with the space capabilities of China and the US. “There’s a little bit of this — us loving ourselves into groups that we don’t belong to,” the astronomer said.Circling back to his Olympics analogy, Kulkarni said countries participate in the Olympics because there is an inherent urge to be seen as the best. “So, planting a flag on the moon or the south pole, I think, has a different dimension. I would put the whole space station in that category, it has no scientific benefits,” he added.

Discover the stories of your interest

The scientist also acknowledges ISRO’s contribution and said it is well respected because it has delivered what it set out to do. “Providing satellite communication and building a land management system for the country’s vast needs. These are straightforward, immediate goals addressing India’s economic and security priorities.”

For the professor, excellence is a key parameter in every domain, and since India lacks resources, the country should focus on strategic areas and look at becoming leaders in those.

Kulkarni also highlighted SpaceX’s reusable rockets as a game changer, noting that legacy companies like Boeing and Northrop are struggling to compete. “Their reusable technology is magnificent. The European Space Agency (ESA) and China haven’t adopted this yet. If SpaceX can launch at 10 times cheaper per kilogram to LEO or GEO, then you’re not in this business anymore,” he explained.

NASA’s space shuttle blunder

“I think NASA made a huge mistake with the space shuttle — it was an enormous waste of money,” said the astronomer whose primary interests are the study of cosmic explosions and developing new methodologies for astronomical research, adding that it is critical to make informed scientific choices.

Kulkarni also questioned the value of the International Space Station (ISS) for drug discovery and new materials, citing limited tangible results over its 20 years of habitation. “If there’s a need for microgravity, I’d love to see tangible results. But before that, tell me why such experiments can’t be conducted on earth. And if there’s big business or money to be made, who has truly profited from it?” he asked.

The scientist, who was awarded for his work on transient astronomical objects, however, acknowledged the importance of understanding the Sun-Earth interaction. “Given how much we rely on satellites now, even a single geomagnetic storm could cause significant disruptions. Today, it’s a global problem and almost an entire industry, including in India.”

Kulkarni pointed out the rise of satellite constellations like Starlink and OneWeb and the private industry’s role in avoiding satellite collisions.

India’s space astronomy efforts fall short

ESA and NASA have extremely large programmes, the Caltech professor said, and if India wants to compete with that, “either we increase the amount of money, or we compete differently — not head-on. Because that’s not practical”.

He also emphasised China’s rise in space astronomy. “They are very secretive about their missions and don’t advertise until it’s all done. But the country has risen extremely rapidly. China is launching major astronomy missions every six months or annually,” Kulkarni said.

He added that India needs a fundamental review of its research framework and to establish a fair and competitive system to evaluate proposals. “Research is mostly confined to standalone institutes, limiting opportunities for undergraduates and diluting the talent pool. This model needs to evolve to include teaching-focused universities with active research programmes.”

Kulkarni also recommended looking at models from the US, Japan, and Europe to adopt best practices in research and space science.



Source link

Share

Latest Updates

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Articles

China’s JD.com moves into food delivery, starts recruiting restaurants

China's e-commerce giant JD.com is venturing into the country's highly competitive food delivery...

Realme P3 Pro Design Teased; to Be Available With a Glow in the Dark Rear Panel

Realme P3 Pro is set to be unveiled in India on February 18....

Texas awards grants to five space companies

WASHINGTON — A Texas state agency awarded $47.7 million in grants to five...

As Elon Musk Reviews Moon Program, Boeing Warns Workers Building Artemis Rocket of Mass Layoffs

Aerospace giant Boeing is warning that hundreds of workers currently working on NASA's...
SULTAN88
SULTANSLOT
RAJA328
JOIN88
GFC88
HOKIBET
RUSIASLOT88
TAHU69
BONANZA99
PRAGMABET
MEGA55
LUXURY777
LUXURY333
BORJU89
QQGAMING
KEDAI168
MEGA777
NAGASLOT777
TAKSU787
KKSLOT777
MAS77TOTO
bandar55
BOS303
HOKI99
NUSA365
YUHUSLOT
KTP168
GALAXY138
NEXIA138
PETIR33
BOOM138
MEGA888
CABE888
FOSIL777
turbospin138
KAPAKBET
SUPERJP
sultankoin99
dragon88
raffi888
kenzobet
aladin666
rgo365
ubm4d
GERCEP88
VIVA99
CR777
VOXY88
delman567
intan69
CABE888
RNR303
LOGO303
PEMBURUGACOR
mpo383
cermin4d
bm88
ANGKA79
WOWHOKI
ROKET303
MPOXL
GURITA168
SUPRASLOT
SGCWIN
DESA88
ARWANA388
DAUNEMAS
ALADDIN666
BIOWIN69
SKY77
DOTA88
NAGA138
API5000
y200m
PLAYBOOK88
LUXURY12
A200M
MPO700
KENANGAN4D
cakrabola
PANDAGENDUT
MARVEL77
UG300
HOKI178
MONTE77
JASABOLA
UNTAR4D
LIDO88
MAFIABOLA77
GASPOL189
mpo999
untung138
TW88
JAGUAR33
MPOBOS
SHIO88
VIVO4D
MPOXL
JARISAKTI
BBO303
AONCASH
ANGKER4D
LEVIS4D
JAGO88
REPUBLIK365
BOSDEAL88
BOLA168
akunjp
WARTEGBET
EZEBET
88PULSA
KITAB4D
BOSDEAL88
STUDIOBET
MESINKOIN
BIMA88
PPNUSA
ABGBET88
TOP77
BAYAR77
YES77
BBTN4D
BBCA4D
VSLOTS88
MPO800
PAHALA4D
KPI4D
JURAGAN77
QQ188
BOLAPELANGI
C200M
QQ998
GWKTOGEL
MEGABANDAR
COLOWIN
VIP579
SEVEN4D
MPO188
DEWATA88
SURAT4D
SINAR123
LAMBO77
GUDANG4D
AWAN4D
PLANETLIGA
GT88
ROYALSPIN88
MAMAJITU
MITO99
PEDIA4D
WIBU69JP
333HOKI
SIDARMA88
NAGAEMAS99
HOLA88
CAKAR76
KINGTOTO
RATUGAMING
SSI168
PILAR168
ACTOTO
EYANGTOGEL
KAISAR328
SLOT628
KAISAR88
DOTA88
MAXWIN369
ALIBABA99
MM168
SQUAD777
NAGABET88
JAYABOLA
SEMPATIGAME
PANDAJAGO
PIKAT4D
SINGA77
YUYU33
MASTERPLAY99
VICTORY39
NASA4D
PERMATA55
SAKAUSLOT
CK303
MPOTOWER
CIPUTRABET
WINJUDI
DEWI5000
IYA777
MAHIRTOTO
GOSLOT88
TIPTOP4D
RAJA787
JBO680
JOKER188
EPICPLAY88
TRIVABET
KAISAR189
JOKER81
JPSPIN88
MAYORA4D
DJARUMPLAY
OVO88
BAKTI78
WINGSLOT77
ICAFE4D
PDTOTO
JETPLAY88
CMBET88
CMBET88
didascaliasdelteatrocaminito.com
glenellynrent.com
gypsumboardequipment.com
realseller.org
https://harrysphone.com/upin
gyergyoalfalu.ro/tokek
vipokno.by/gokil
winjospg.com
winjos801.com/
www.logansquarerent.com
internationalfintech.com/bamsz
condowizard.ca
jawatoto889.com
hikaribet3.live
hikaribet1.com
heylink.me/hikaribet
www.nomadsumc.org
condowizard.ca/aromatoto
euro2024gol.com
www.imaracorp.com
daftarsekaibos.com
stuffyoucanuse.org/juragan
Toto Macau 4d
Aromatoto
Lippototo
Mbahtoto
Winjos
152.42.229.23
bandarlotre126.com
heylink.me/sekaipro
www.get-coachoutletsonline.com
wholesalejerseyslord.com
Lippototo
Zientoto
Lippototo
Situs Togel Resmi
Fajartoto
Situs Togel
Toto Macau
Winjos
Winlotre
Aromatoto
design-develop-test.com
winlotre.online
winlotre.xyz
winlotre.us
winlotrebandung.com
winlotrepalu.com
winlotresurabaya.shop
winlotrejakarta.com
winlotresemarang.shop
winlotrebali.shop
winlotreaceh.shop
winlotremakmur.com
Dadu Online
Taruhantoto
a Bandarlotre
bursaliga
lakitoto
aromatoto
Rebahin
untungslot.pages.dev
slotpoupler.pages.dev
rtpliveslot88a.pages.dev
tipsgameslot.pages.dev
pilihslot88.pages.dev
fortuertiger.pages.dev
linkp4d.pages.dev
linkslot88a.pages.dev
slotpgs8.pages.dev
markasjudi.pages.dev
saldo69.pages.dev
slotbenua.pages.dev
saingtoto.pages.dev
markastoto77.pages.dev
jowototo88.pages.dev
sungli78.pages.dev
volatilitas78.pages.dev
bonusbuy12.pages.dev
slotoffiline.pages.dev
dihindari77.pages.dev
rtpdislot1.pages.dev
agtslot77.pages.dev
congtoto15.pages.dev
hongkongtoto7.pages.dev
sinarmas177.pages.dev
hours771.pages.dev
sarana771.pages.dev
kananslot7.pages.dev
balitoto17.pages.dev
jowototo17.pages.dev
aromatotoding.com
unyagh.org
fairparkcounseling.com/gap/
impress-newtex.com/ajax/
SULTAN88
SULTANSLOT
RAJA328
JOIN88+
HOKIBET
GFC88
RusiaSlot88
Tahu69
BONANZA99
Pragmabet
mega55
luxury777
luxury333
borju89
qqgaming
KEDAI168
mega777
nagaslot777
TAKSU787
kkslot777
MAS77TOTO
BANDAR55+
BOS303
Login-HOKI99/
NUSA365
YUHUSLOT
ktp168
GALAXY138