Read the Antitrust Ruling Against Google



Case 1:23-cv-00108-LMB-JFA Document 1410
Filed 04/17/25
Page 105 of 115
PageID# 103785
improved safety and privacy, countered fraud, reduced latency, promoted investment, and
decreased prices.
A defendant shown to have engaged in exclusionary conduct to maintain a monopoly
may avoid Section 2 liability by proving that the conduct was done for “valid business reasons.”
Kodak, 504 U.S. at 483; see LePage’s, 324 F.3d at 163. Accordingly, procompetitive rationales
may justify “an otherwise per se illegal tying arrangement.” Mozart Co. v. Mercedes-Benz of N.
Am., Inc., 833 F.2d 1342, 1348 (9th Cir. 1987). A court must assess the “validity and sufficiency
of each claimed [procompetitive] justification.” Kodak, 504 U.S. at 483; see also Duke Energy,
111 F.4th at 362, 365; Viamedia, 951 F.3d at 464; Microsoft, 253 F.3d at 66. Because pretextual
and unsubstantiated justifications are not “valid,” Kodak, 504 U.S. at 483; see Actavis, 787 F.3d
at 658; McWane, 783 F.3d at 841-42, courts may give “greater weight to the contemporaneous
statements contained in the company’s internal records, than [to] later trial testimony in which
[its] employees declined to ratify those statements.” Google Search, 2024 WL 3647498, at *41
n.2; see also United States v. U.S. Gypsum Co., 333 U.S. 364, 395–400 (1948). In assessing
whether proffered procompetitive justifications are “sufficient,” Kodak, 504 U.S. at 483, courts
frequently “balance the restriction’s anticompetitive harms against its procompetitive benefits.”
Epic Games, 67 F.4th at 994; see Alston, 594 U.S. at 96–97; Microsoft, 253 F.3d at 59, 66; FTC
v. Qualcomm Inc., 969 F.3d 974, 991 (9th Cir. 2020).
Google has failed to proffer a sufficient procompetitive justification for its AdX-DFP tie,
as each procompetitive benefit it alleged was either invalid or significantly outweighed by the
tie’s anticompetitive effects. Google contends that the integration of its products across the ad
tech stack, including the AdX-DFP tie, reduced spam, fraud, malware, latency, and other quality
issues; however, Google documents show that the buy-side AdWords team, which was
105



Source link

Share

Latest Updates

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Articles

Fixing Hallucinations Would Destroy ChatGPT, Expert Finds

In a paper published earlier this month, OpenAI researchers said they'd found the...

Centre’s AI roadmap targets $1.7 trillion GDP boost by 2035

New Delhi: The government aims to generate additional $1.7 trillion in economic value...

Google to bring iPhone-style live video sharing to Android Emergencies

Smartphones play a crucial role during emergencies, allowing users to quickly notify emergency...
sabung ayam online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online Sabung Ayam Online Sv388 Sv388 SV388 sabung ayam online sabung ayam online Sabung Ayam Online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online Sabung ayam online Sabung ayam online SV388 sabung ayam online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online sabung ayam online SV388 sabung ayam online SV388 SV388 Sabung Ayam Online Sabung Ayam Online Sabung Ayam Online Sabung Ayam Online Sv388 SV388 SV388 sabung ayam online sv388 sv388 sabung ayam online sv388
judi bola judi bola Judi bola SBOBET judi bola judi bola judi bola Judi Bola Online judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola juara303 juara303 Judi bola online judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola SBOBET judi bola judi bola judi bola Judi Bola SBOBET88 SBOBET88 judi bola judi bola judi bola JUDI BOLA ONLINE JUDI BOLA ONLINE SBOBET88 Judi Bola Judi Bola judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola Judi Bola Online judi bola judi bola judi bola judi bola mix parlay
CASINO ONLINE SLOT GACOR live casino mahjong ways Live Casino Online Slot Gacor Mahjong Ways slot pulsa Casino Online Slot Gacor Mix Parlay live casino online live casino online LIVE CASINO ONLINE LIVE CASINO ONLINE slot pulsa slot pulsa slot pulsa Mpo Slot
https://ejurnal.staidarulkamal.ac.id/ https://doctorsnutritionprogram.com/ https://nielsen-restaurante.com/ https://www.atobapizzaria.com.br/ https://casadeapoio.com.br/ https://bracoalemao.com.br/ https://letspetsresort.com.br/ https://mmsolucoesweb.com.br/ https://procao.com.br/
Rahasia Kemenangan di Mahjong Wild Pemain Tidak Menyangka Pola Scatter Jangan Anggap Remeh Mahjong Wild Pemain Pemula Heran Setelah Coba Mahjong Wild Menemukan Pola Rahasia yang Bikin Scatter Muncul Pola Scatter Rahasia yang Baru Terbongkar Pola Rahasia Pemain Pemula Terbongkar Mereka Ketagihan Karena Sering Dapat Kemenangan Mereka Ketagihan Karena Sering Dapat Kemenangan Trik Sederhana Saat Taruhan Kecil Pola Wild Liar Tersembunyi Bisa Menggandakan uang Pola Rahasia Baru Bisa Menghasilkan Wild Buktikan Pola Wild Liar dan Scatter Hitam Kaya Setelah Main Mahjong Wild Pria Asal Nepal Obrak-Abarik Kantor DPR